Saturday

Caitlin Atwater’s life was shattered when her mother died in an accident. After an investigation, police charged Caitlin’s stepdad with murder. It turned out that Michael Peterson was hiding a terrible secret & it wasn’t the first time he’d killed.

In a frantic 911 call as he raced his bleeding wife to the hospital, hog farmer Todd Mullis told dispatchers Amy Mullis accidentally fell on a four-pronged corn rake in their barn. But when investigators found more than four holes in Amy’s body, they knew her death was no accident.

Charities lavished gifts on Gypsy Lee Blanchard, a sympathetic young girl confined to a wheelchair. The Make-a-wish foundation sent her on trips and Habitat for Humanity built her a home. But it all came to end when her mother was found murdered and Gypsy went missing, leaving her wheelchair behind. As the murder investigation got underway the local Sheriff reported “Things aren’t exactly what they seemed to be”.

Augustine had a rocky start in life, including a famous mother cut down in her prime by a grasping, murderous husband. But when she met Jessie McCaskill it seemed her life had fallen into place. Initially blissfully in love, their marriage soon descended into violence, substance abuse, and ultimately death.